Is Moncrieff’s Chemical Imbalance Paper a Decent Systematic Umbrella Review?

James Coyne

James Coyne response to Robert Rubin

Bob, your paper with Jay Armstrong adds to my black swan defeat of Joanna Moncrieff's conclusion of her systematic umbrella review. By committing herself so completely to "serotonin is dead," she is vulnerable to a few papers that show it is not. 

I have some biological psychiatrists in the UK providing other examples. 

December 1, 2022